City College
Jake Bermejo
Class: English Composition 21003
10/25/16
Untold truth behind Schizophrenia and Dementia
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to discuss the similarities and differences between schizophrenia and dementia. Although both categorized as neurological disorders, dementia in my opinion has proven itself to be far more severe and diverse with its long term effects. It’s a disorder that comes in many forms mostly around the age of 60 and over. Schizophrenia is an early onset disorder and appears mostly around the time of teenagers. To prove such a claim I used several sources starting from the American Psychiatric Association ranging to the American College of Physicians of Family Physicians on Dementia. I even used statistical data from the Alzheimer's Association and Schizophrenia International Association to portray a comprehensive and thorough evaluation of both disorders. Ultimately providing me with an outcome that although categorized both similarly, dementia is a disorder that has effects that have far surpassed schizophrenia in the long run.
Schizophrenia and dementia are both neurological disorders that change thousands of people's lives everyday. Although they share similar problematical symptoms, dementia has had numerous accounts of people being left with non reversible effects. Such effects include loss in memory, delusions, violent behavior, as well as the inability to perform basic daily activities like eating and showering. This does not only put a lot of strain on a persons thoughts, emotions, and behavior.It can also leave a person relying on a caretaker for the rest of their lives.Schizophrenia also affects a person's life in the same manner but only for a certain period of time since it is highly treatable. Although, schizophrenia and dementia are categorized together as similar illnesses, dementia is far more diverse and severe than schizophrenia.
Over the years, the treatment for dementia has acquired so much money and patients for “dementia care” that at one point it was actually considered enough to to be able to start a new country (Alzheimer’s Disease International, “Dementia Statistics”).In a poll taken within the last century for demographic aging, the percentage of elderly people in the world's population actually managed to increase due to health care improvements. This not only made dementia a crucial factor in the economical development for “dementia care” but also added more awareness of dementia throughout the world (Alzheimer’s Disease International, “Dementia Statistics”).
In 2002, the treatment for schizophrenia was over 62.7 billion dollars and the total amount of patients were about 2.6 million (Hawkes Eric,Marvin Ross. “Schizophrenia Facts and Statistics”).
This was nothing but a small fraction of what “dementia care” had at the time. According to the figure above, every year there is about 9.9 million new cases of dementia (Alzheimer’s Disease International, “Dementia Statistics”). There is literally ongoing revenue happening within every 3 seconds that a new case appears. The total cost worldwide in the U.S in 2015 was 18 billion dollars. By 2030, it will rise to two trillion dollars in medicare. Almost 46.8 million people worldwide have dementia. In the Americas about 9.4 million people have it, in africa 4 million, Europe 10.5 million, and Asia has 22.9 million people with dementia. And these numbers will only continue to double every 20 years.It will come to rise by 68% in 2050 in low and middle income countries that can’t afford dementia care (Alzheimer’s Disease International, “Dementia Statistics”). If global dementia care were a country it would be the 18th largest economy in the world right next to apple and google. That could possibly leave the U.S in a high deficit for dementia care that people would no longer be able to afford it. Schizophrenia on the other hand shows a lot of promise for being treated and handled with minimal costs.
Schizophrenia is a disease that begins in a person's young adulthood. Schizophrenia has had several medical breakthroughs that involve 15 new type of medications like "psycho-social therapy and cognitive therapy"(Hawkes Eric,Marvin Ross. “Schizophrenia Facts and Statistics”). In schizophrenia, genes like dysbindin,neuregulin, and G72 genes all relate to different neuron cells found within the brain just like in alzheimer's. The only difference is that schizophrenia also incorporates environmental factors that can ultimately "trigger" the disorder (Hawkes Eric,Marvin Ross. “Schizophrenia Facts and Statistics”). so the environmental factors for both would be severely different. A teenager with schizophrenia would still live as a dependent in the family and still be able to take care of themselves by taking certain medications for the illness.While a person over 60 with Alzheimer's, would most likely be left under the care of a caretaker. This is mainly because "when dementia does occur, it usually only gets worse" as time goes on (Borson Soo, etc al. “The Journal of Alzheimers Association”).This would be the only upside to being diagnosed with schizophrenia instead of dementia since it is highly treatable. Although treatment for dementia involves psychotherapy, certain antipsychotic drugs, and mostly staying in a hospital for a short period of time it can only deviate the process to an extent where a person can just barely cope with it. Schizophrenia on the other hand gives people hope and the ability to look at a better tomorrow. This cannot be said about dementia since is no real treatment for dementia. There are only different ways to deal with it until you die. That is the difference between the reality of dementia and schizophrenia. Dementia’s impact in society leaves it as not just another illness you can take medication for like in schizophrenia. This mainly due to its different forms. One main prevalent main form of dementia is Alzheimer's disease.
Alzheimer's is a disease that is mostly found in the elderly.This disease kills the neuron cells found within a person’s brain that involves their memory, language, and perception. It can be inherited through a relative's genes just like in schizophrenia.When one family member is diagnosed with schizophrenia there is a 7 to 9 percent risk that it can also be carried onto the next member. Although this doesn’t seem like much, most people who do not even consider the slightest risks are usually the ones receiving treatment when it's already too late. After that most teenagers that are diagnosed with schizophrenia mostly look at suicide as the only way out. Suicide is the number one cause of premature death in patients diagnosed with schizophrenia. This is mainly because of the “extreme depression” and “psychoses” that occur in schizophrenia that amplify the average thoughts of suicide in teenagers to being around 50 times greater (Hawkes Eric,Marvin Ross. “Schizophrenia Facts and Statistics”). Suicidal thoughts in patients are also symptoms of dementia but are more controlled because of the difference in age groups. Most elderly groups have already lived out their lives and see no harm in dying. Teenagers however, are more emotional about living their lives to its fullest extent and often see illnesses like schizophrenia as blockages in their lives that can only be overcome by death.
As seen above the relative prevalence of schizophrenia is 2x greater than alzheimer's.This type of difference not only leaves schizophrenia with a bad image since so many kids are being diagnosed with such a malicious disease but also adds on another reason as to why the illness is so treatable. Since suicidal thoughts mainly results from a patient's depression and low self esteem. The easiest way to cure them is to have them talk it out in therapy where they can readdress their actions and thoughts by finally getting the help they need. However, dementia cannot be solved this easily since it's not just another part of normal aging. It's a disorder that can come from having “multiple sclerosis, brain injuries, and even “progressive supranuclear palsy” (Qaseem A, American College of Physicians of Family Physicians Panel on Dementia)
Which according to figure 2, also shows that schizophrenia has a 5 times greater prevalence rate than multiple sclerosis. These type of symptoms can leave a person unable to control their sense of judgement and direction. This can result in “poor judgment” and “the loss of the ability to recognize danger”. Proving that dementia is very diverse and can be a result of many conditions within the brain. It is not just limited to being caused by a person’s genetics or environmental background like in schizophrenia.
Today some people that have dementia, deal with the disease by turning to their families or loved ones to take care of them. Other people rely on caretakers but the one thing they don’t do is act independently.There always has to be someone there to help them do their basic daily activities like eating, showering, drinking, and dressing themselves. After being diagnosed with dementia, most people find it hard to believe that nothing will ever be under their control again. Schizophrenia also belongs to the same category of neurological disorders since it does alter a person’s brain function. It can even revolutionize a person’s lifestyle to a point where they’ll have to take different medications on a daily basis. But it will never have the same non reversible effects dementia has. Neither will it be as diverse and well known as dementia.It will only just be another neurological disorder that has similiar symptoms but not the same diversity or severity that dementia has.
Works Cited Page
-American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 5th ed. Arlington, Va: American Psychiatric Publishing. 2013.
-Borson, Soo, Lori Frank, Peter J. Bayley, Malaz Boustani, Marge Dean, Pei-Jung Lin, J. Riley McCarten, John C. Morris, David P. Salmon, Frederick A. Schmitt, Richard G. Stefanacci, Marta S. Mendiondo, Susan Peschin, Eric J. Hall, Howard Fillit, and J. Wesson Ashford. "Improving Dementia Care: The Role of Screening and Detection of Cognitive Impairment." Alzheimer's & Dementia : The Journal of the Alzheimer's Association. U.S. National Library of Medicine, Mar. 2013. Web. 26 Oct. 2016.
-Qaseem A, et al., American College of Physicians/American Academy of Family Physicians Panel on Dementia. Current pharmacologic treatment of dementia: a clinical practice guideline from the American College of Physicians and the American Academy of Family Physicians. Ann Intern Med. 2008;148:370-378.
-Association, Alzheimer's. "2013 Alzheimer's Disease Facts and Figures." National Center for Biotechnology Information. U.S. National Library of Medicine, n.d. Web. 26 Oct. 2016.
-Hawkes,Eric, and Marvin Ross. "Schizophrenia Facts and Statistics."Schizophrenia Facts and Statistics. Brian Chiko, 1995. Web. 26 Oct. 2016.
-"Dementia Statistics." Alzheimer's Disease International. Alzheimer's Disease International, 1984. Web. 26 Oct. 2016.
No comments:
Post a Comment